Theatre Reservations

    Package Reservations

Make Lodging Reservations


The National Home of Plain and Fancy

Plain and FancyMay 29 - October 19
Book by Joseph Stein and Will Glickman
Music by Albert Hague
Lyrics by Arnold B. Horwitt
Produced by special arrangement with Samuel French, Inc.

A New Yorker and his sophisticated girlfriend drive down to Bird-in-Hand, Pennsylvania, to sell a piece of property. Here they interact with the Amish community, whose convoluted English speech, clothes and habits have remained the same for centuries. It was the first Broadway show for both composer Albert Hague and author Joseph Stein who each went on to win Tony awards for Redhead and Fiddler On The Roof, respectively.

Amish Acres has become the national home of this 1955 Broadway hit. This 2013 production marks the 27th consecutive year that The Round Barn Theatre has produced Plain and Fancy.

"Opening Night was sensational. Had no idea it was going to be so hysterical. Looking forward to seeing another performance." - Joyce (Theatre Patron)

Scenes & Musical Numbers
Director Notes
Cast Bios
Production Staff Bios
Theme Dinners
Plain and Fancy Press Release
Read a History of Plain and Fancy
Read a Recent Review of Plain and Fancy in The Pilot News
Read a Recent Review of Plain and Fancy in The Papers


Amish Acres







Amish Acres



A Note from the Director…

Amish AcresAfter I directed Plain and Fancy in 2009, I believed I was hanging up my Amish hat forever.  I walked out the lobby doors perfectly content with the contribution I had made to its unique and marvelous history.  How does one rekindle a romance that has lain dormant for so long?  The short answer is: stepping away from the show for a few years allowed me to gain an entirely new perspective on the world. Theatre is one of the only professions I can think of where just getting older benefits you. It is in my nature as an actor to absorb everything around me for later use on stage, and going back out into the world and experiencing life in many different places and on many levels was perhaps the best medicine I could have asked for.  I suddenly found myself ready to make a return journey to Bird-in-Hand with renewed enthusiasm for this charming love story and all of the lives it has touched.  My thanks to an excellent cast and crew for helping breathe new life into a once weary vision, and to you, our patrons, for continuing to support our “Little Show That Could” year after year.  Cheers!

Jeremy Littlejohn


A Note from the Music Director…

Welcome to Plain and Fancy!  It's hard to believe that this is my fourth year music directing the show.  How time flies!  I often wonder how many times some of our regular patrons have seen Plain and Fancy.  It has to be interesting for them to see how the show evolves each year into something new.  Whether it is because there is a new director or a new cast or even a new music director, there is always something fresh about the show even after 27 years.  Because I have music directed the show several times in the past, it can be easy for me to get set in my ways and allow the music to get stale.  But thankfully we are breathing some new life into the show this year, not only with a new cast but also with a new perspective from returning director Jeremy Littlejohn.  This new approach has helped to keep me on my toes and willing to try new things!  As always, thank you for supporting live theatre and the arts.  Enjoy the show!

Travis Smith


Plain and Fancy Cast


Dan King


Rory Dunn

Ruth Winters


Sarah Philabaum

Katie Yoder


Angie Fisher

Papa Yoder


Don Hart

Isaac Miller


Timothy Leonard

Emma Miller


Emily Dunn

Hilda Miller


Ruth Olson

Ezra Reber


Trent Loggins

Peter Reber


Steven Freitas


Plain and Fancy Staff


Executive Producer


Richard Pletcher

Associate Producer


George Bush

Artistic Director


Jeremy Littlejohn

Music Director


Travis Smith

Production Stage Manager/Props


Monica Gauer

Technical Director


Justin Detwiler

Company Manager


Timothy Leonard

Set Designer


Richard Pletcher

Lighting Designer


Jeremy Littlejohn

Dance Captain


Sarah Philabaum

Master Carpenter


Gary Balogh

Box Office Manager


Jennifer Scheffer

Archive Videographer


Steve Jones


Scenes and Musical Numbers

Act I


Scene 1 A Shell Station Outside of Lancaster


You Can't Miss It

Dan, Ruth, Company

Scene 2 The Road to Bird-in-Hand


It Wonders Me

Katie, Company

Scene 3 A Rest Stop Outside of Bird-in-Hand


Scene 4 The Yoder Yard


Plenty of Pennsylvania

Emma, Company

Young and Foolish  


Scene 5 The Yoder Parlor


Why Not Katie?

Ezra, Isaac

Scene 6 The Yoder Yard


Young and Foolish (Reprise)

Katie, Peter

Scene 7 The Little Room Under the Stairs


It's A Helluva Way to Run a Love Affair


This is All Very New to Me


Scene 8 The Yoder Yard


Plain We Live

Papa, Company

Scene 9 The Yoder Yard


The Shunning (Plain We Live: Reprise)

Papa, Katie, Company

Act II


Scene 1 The River Farm


How Do You Raise a Barn?


Follow Your Heart

Peter, Katie, Hilda

Scene 2 The Yoder Kitchen


City Mouse, Country Mouse

Emma, Isaac

Scene 3 The Yoder Parlor


Scene 4 The Little Room Under the Stairs


I'll Show Him


Scene 5 The Reber Yard


Young and Foolish (Reprise)


Scene 6 The Yoder Yard


Finale (Plenty of Pennsylvania: Reprise)



Cast Biographies

Emily Dunn (Emma) is looking forward to being a part of the season for her seventh year. Some of her favorite memories at the Round Barn include a sword taking her wig off unexpectedly in The Pirates of Penzance, finishing Plain and Fancy at the audiences request while in the hallway due to a tornado warning in 2006, and having her best friend propose during the 2012 New Years Eve Cabaret. She is thrilled to be back and performing with her wonderful hubby. 



Rory Dunn (Dan King) is happy to be back at The Round Barn Theatre for his 3rd year. This year he is able to finally fulfill a life-long dream by showing the world he isn't afraid to play the Cowardly Lion! Recently Rory wed the love of his life, you knew her as Emily Baer, and can't wait to do it again in every performance of Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. 


Angie Fisher (Katie) is a recent graduate of the BFA Music Theatre program at Southern Illinois University in Carbondale.  She appeared in many productions there including Judy in Irving Berlin’s White Christmas, Joanne in Rent, Irene in Crazy for You and April in Company.  Professional credits include Kitty in The Drowsy Chaperone and Judy in A Chorus Line at McLeod Summer Playhouse.  She would like to thank her family and friends for the six and a half hour drive it takes to be here to see her!




Steven Freitas (Peter) is excited to be back on stage at The Round Barn Theatre for the 2013 season! You may have seen him as Felix Unger in Neil Simon's, The Odd Couple back in 2011. Since then Steven relocated to the California coast performing for the past year and a half in such places as The Great American Melodrama and Vaudeville and a newly opened theatre, The SPOT.  A native of New England and graduate of the University of New Hampshire's theatre program with a degree in both acting and musical theatre, Steven has performed throughout the US, working in both theatre and television. Past credits include The Man Who Came to Dinner with the late James Whitmore, Dog Sees God: Confessions of a Teenage Blockhead as CB, Sunday in the Park with George asJules, The Laramie Project as Jedadiah Schultz, A Little Night Music as Henrik Egerman, and A Christmas Carol as Bob Cratchit, among others. Steven also performed with the sketch comedy troupe, American Candy, at NYC's acclaimed Gotham Comedy Club and can be seen as a recurring character on PBS’ reboot of The Electric Company. 

A special thank you to my family, friends, and Crystal for all of your constant love and support.


Don Hart (Papa) is pleased to be back at the Round Barn Theatre, and for the opportunity to portray Papa Yoder!  Other RBT roles include Samuel in The Pirates of Penzance, Henry in The Fantasticks, Eddie in Pump Boys and Dinettes and Isaac in Plain and Fancy.  Don has also performed as John Denver in Almost Heaven at Pines Dinner Theatre in Allentown, PA, Johnny Cash in Ring of Fire at Derby Dinner Theatre in Clarksville, IN, and Gerald Drimmond in There Goes The Bride at Sierra Repertory Theatre in Sonora, CA.

Love ya, Crystal!



Amish AcresTimothy Leonard (Isaac / Company Manager) attended Florida School of the Arts for Musical Theatre before moving on to the National Tour of A Christmas Carol in 2008.  Since then he has performed in such shows as Oklahoma!, Smoke on the Mountain, and various children’s theatre projects.  In 2011, Timothy began performing here at the Round Barn Theatre where he has enjoyed playing a diverse assortment of roles including Judge Heppenstall in State Fair, Vinnie in The Odd Couple and Hank in Hank Williams: Lost Highway among others.  When asked about his continued work here at Amish Acres, he said: “We’re a family – the audience and community feel that way to me.  I recognize many faces each season, and do my utmost to give them an enjoyable experience every time they visit.”


Trent Loggins (Ezra) hails from Morris, AL.  Trent recently graduated with a BFA from the University of Montevallo.  He loves good food and good times with friends.  Regional favorites: Ralph Malph in Happy Days in Ohio, Rev. Shermerhorn in Unto These Hills in NC, and most recently Pa Lincoln in Young Abe Lincoln in Alabama.

Thanks to Mom, Dad, Mason and Lindley for their endless love and support.  Roll Tide!



Ruth Olson (Hilda) is a native of Mishawaka and a 2011 graduate of Bethel College with a B.A. in Vocal Performance.  Since then, she has moved to (and from) Colorado Springs where she taught first grade and worked with Focus on the Family, and climbed her first “fourteener.”  When she is not on stage, she can be found at her “other” job as a physical therapy aide at Goshen Hospital.

I am deeply grateful to so many people for their love and support over the years – Mom, Courtney, Bob & Marilynn, Dan & Karen, Vicki G., my grandparents…and many more.  Most of all, my dear Friend and Lord, Jesus Christ.  May the glory be all yours.”


Amish AcresSarah Philabaum (Ruth) is so happy to be returning to the Round Barn Theatre for her third season in a row!  You may remember her from last year’s productions of State Fair, Hank Williams: Lost Highway and Plain and Fancy.  Sarah earned her BFA in Musical Theatre from Shenandoah Conservatory and for the past few years has been traveling around the country performing for audiences both young and old.  She has really enjoyed touring with the National Theatre for Children as well as the National Tour of A Christmas Carol.  Sarah loves coming back to the Round Barn each year and would like to thank the many patrons who continually support live theatre.

Enjoy the show!


Staff Biographies

Gary Balogh (Master Carpenter) was born in Ohio, and raised in Indiana north of Fort Wayne.  He studied Architectural Design, Civil Engineering and Surveying at Purdue University and Ivy Tech.  Prior to joining the Amish Acres team in 2012, Gary worked in the Construction field as a Heavy Equipment Operator.  He also has built sets for his church’s Bible School plays for several years.  He likes to build and fix “whatever”.

George Bush (Associate Producer) is a Nappanee native and proud graduate of Northwood High School!  George began his work at Amish Acres as a trash collector at age 14 and spent much of his educational career (both high school and college) with Amish Acres as an intern, clerk in the hotel, Art Festival food runner and in retail.  George started a family in Muncie where he attended Ball State University and worked in the property development world for ten years.  He returned to Nappanee in 2011, where he was named Chief Operating Officer for Amish Acres and Associate Producer for the Round Barn Theatre.  He is extremely happy to have his family relocated back home and is looking forward to a wonderful 2013 season.

Justin Detwiler (Technical Director) is a life long resident of Nappanee who graduated from Northwood High School in 1995. Upon graduating from high school, Justin studied at Defiance College. After studying at college for 1 year, he decided to join the working class, and spent the next 15 years working as a carpenter in the construction field.  For 13 of those years, he was a job sight foreman. In 2010, Justin started his work for Amish Acres as a sub contractor.  Later that season, he was named Supervisor of Property and Grounds and in January of 2013, he was named Technical Director for the Round Barn Theatre. Justin has been happily married to his wife Stacey since 2001 and they have two daughters; 9 year old Haley and 7 year old Olivia.  Justin is very excited to be Technical Director for the 2013 season!

Monica Gauer (Production Stage Manager) had so much fun stage managing last year; she decided to stick around for another year!  Monica grew up in Laporte, Indiana (surrounded by friends and family), then graduated from the University of Southern Indiana (where she made new friends), after which she got married (turning her best friend into her family), and now she is helping to build a bigger Round Barn family (and she hopes you will become part of it).  When she isn’t busy around the Acres she loves to read, watch cartoons and listen to stories…and storytelling is what theater is all about!  So relax and enjoy a story that Monica and her Round Barn family are about to tell you.

Christopher Lidl (Sound) is a Show Production Specialist from Pawling, NY. He won an award for Excellence in Theatre at Trinity Pawling School in 2008. He attended Full Sail University down in Orlando where he has a Bachelor’s Degree in Show Production.  When he is not in the theater, he enjoys bike riding, hiking and socializing.

Jeremy Littlejohn (Artistic Director) is a native Hoosier who is thrilled to be celebrating his fifth season as Artistic Director for the RBT.  Jeremy has worked at Amish Acres in three different decades both on the Joseph Stein Stage and in the Historic Area.  He is probably remembered for his performance credits, but is most proud of introducing straight plays to the Round Barn audience by way of the Second Stage.  He has logged nearly 800 performances of Plain and Fancy playing all of the male roles, and directed the show five times; including the 20th Anniversary season.  Some of his other directing projects include Nunsense, The Glass Menagerie, Bye Bye, Birdie, Miss Nelson is Missing, Driving Miss Daisy, Thoroughly Modern Millie, Lost in Yonkers, Irving Berlin’s White Christmas, Kiss Me Kate, Guys and Dolls (with Bethel College), and his Masterwork, Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Carousel.  In addition to being an Actor / Director, Jeremy is also an accomplished Lighting Designer, Stage Manager and Teacher.

“Fairy tales are more than true; not because they tell us dragons exist, but because they tell us dragons can be beaten.”  - G.K. Chesterton

Richard Pletcher (Executive Producer) founded Amish Acres with his father LaVern in 1968. The Amish farm was preserved and restored and is now listed in The National Register of Historic Places. Following a one year experiment in dinner-theatre with George Bledsoe in 1971, he added musical theatre to the interpretation of the historic farm by producing Plain and Fancy in the Locke Township Meeting House in 1986. It moved to The Round Barn Theatre in 1991. The play has been running for 26 consecutive years having surpassed 3,700 performances before audiences of over 355,000 people. Plain and Fancy’s Tony Award® winning author Joseph Stein and Tony Award® winning composer Albert Hague have attended Plain and Fancy at Amish Acres.

At Joseph Stein’s urging, Amish Acres became a regional musical repertory theatre in 1996 with the addition of five shows in rotation with Plain and Fancy each season. Amish Acres has now produced over one hundred Broadway musicals and The Round Barn Theatre stage is named for and dedicated to Joseph Stein. Seven of Mr. Stein’s musicals have been produced on his stage, including Plain and Fancy, Fiddler on the Roof, The Baker’s Wife, and Zorba, plus staged readings of Take Me Along, Rags and a second stage production of Enter Laughing.  

In October of 2006, Dick and his wife Susan were guests of Joseph and Elisa Stein in New York City for the York Theatre’s Mufti Series production of Plain and Fancy, the last in a month long, three show festival of Stein’s work that included Take Me Along and Carmelina. Artistic Director James Morgan recognized Amish Acres’ 20 year production of Plain and Fancy in the program and in his introductions from the stage. The Pletcher’s and Jeremy Littlejohn attended the York’s presentation of the Oscar Hammerstein Lifetime Achievement Award in Musical Theatre to Joseph Stein in November of 2007.  Stein was further inducted into the Theatre Hall of Fame in February of 2008. He passed away in 2010 and the Joseph Stein Memorial Fund was created to provide free season tickets for children.

Travis Smith (Music Director) is excited to be back at Amish Acres again this year after being active here as both an actor and music director since 2009.  Previous productions at Amish Acres include State Fair, Sisters of Swing, Smoke on the Mountain: Homecoming and Miracle on 34th Street.  He is also a composer and arranger currently working on a new production titled Steeple People about a southern gospel quartet.  Please visit his website for more information.

Enjoy the show and thank you for supporting live theatre!


Plain and Fancy
Theme Dinner: May 31

Each Round Barn theatre Musical production calls for a Theme Dinner and Wine Bar, a joyous celebration with menus written with tongue-in-cheek show references and double entendres, often obscure and ridiculous. the responsibility for such frivolity rest solely with Richard Pletcher. The ensuing menus are lovingly prepared by chef Ruth Miller whose sense of humor make it into it kettle and skillet.

Theme Dinner reservations required. 
For reservations call (800) 800-4942.

Plenty of Pennsylvania

Menu Includes:

Broccoli and Cheese Soup

Tortilla Pinwheels
Fruit Kabob
Vegetables and Dip

Iceburg Lettuce Quarters with Tomatoes, Onions

Zucchini Bread
Pumpkin Bread

Swiss Steak with Mushrooms
Pan Fried Chicken

Chicken and Noodles

Candied Yams
Cooked Dried Corn

Old Fashioned Cream Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Shoofly Pie
Ruth's Famous Creme Brule

Planters Punch,
Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffees
Beer and Wine available for purchase