Theatre Reservations

    Package Reservations

Make Lodging Reservations


The National Home of Plain and Fancy

May 28 - October 18
Book by Joseph Stein and Will Glickman
Music by Albert Hague
Lyrics by Arnold B. Horwitt
Produced by special arrangement with Samuel French, Inc.

A New Yorker and his sophisticated girlfriend drive down to Bird-in-Hand, Pennsylvania, to sell a piece of property. Here they interact with the Amish community, whose convoluted English speech, clothes and habits have remained the same for centuries. Plain and Fancy was the first Broadway show for both composer Albert Hague and author Joseph Stein who each went on to win Tony awards for Redhead and Fiddler On The Roof, respectively.

The Round Barn Theatre has become the national home of this 1955 Broadway hit. This 2014 production marks the 28th consecutive year that The Round Barn Theatre has produced Plain and Fancy making it one of the longest running shows anywhere.  Simply “Incredible.”

Scenes & Musical Numbers
Director Notes
Cast Bios
Production Staff Bios
Theme Dinners
Plain and Fancy Press Release
Read a History of Plain and Fancy
Read a Recent Story about Plain and Fancy in the Sound Bend Tribune
Read a Recent Review about Plain and Fancy in The Papers
Read a Recent Review about Plain and Fancy by Frank Ramirez

Amish Acres




A Note from the Director…

Has it been 28 years already? Ironically, when I turned 28, I had just directed this show for the first time. It was my first “musical” directing effort, which made it more comfortable, as I already had about 300 performances under my belt by that time. It is amazing to think of the evolution I have gone through as a human during 28 years; and then to compare that to what a quaint musical can accomplish in the same amount of time is quite interesting. This beautiful Broadway musical boasts an alumnus cast of nearly 500 with over 3,000 performances logged for about 300,000 patrons. It has literally been running long enough for patrons to see it as children and then take their own children to it after they are grown. I have often felt that Plain and Fancy and I sort of grew up together. Just in my time with the show, I had the great fortune to witness countless interpretations of these characters, and developed many life long friendships with cast and staff members… and that’s before even getting into what the text and score have taught me about directing musical theatre. As I prepared to direct the show for the sixth time, it has been extremely important for me to reflect upon what this show has meant to me artistically and emotionally. For better or worse, Plain and Fancy has changed my life, and I am looking forward to what the next 28 years will bring for both of us.

“Who can say if I’ve been changed for the better? I do believe I have been changed for the better. Because I knew you, I have been changed for good. – Stephen Schwartz

Jeremy Littlejohn

A Note from the Music Director…

Thank you for coming!  What a pleasure it is to be given the opportunity to music direct the 28th anniversary of Plain and Fancy here at the Round Barn Theatre.  Much can be said about the delightful music within the show written by Albert Hague over 50 years ago.  Albert Hague, perhaps most famous for composing the tunes from "How The Grinch Stole Christmas", was also an actor having been seen in such films as “Fame” and “Space Jam” and many TV shows including the TV series of “Fame” and “Amazing Stories.”  His music for Plain and Fancy is mostly traditional and seemingly inspired by his German heritage, yet on occasion it is somewhat experimental for the time.  Listen carefully to "You Can't Miss It" and how its various melodies compliment the lyrics in a way that makes it seem almost conversational, the notes reflecting speech patterns in a way that Sondheim and other current composers have mastered with their music today.  Hague even jazzes up the score a little with such numbers as “Helluva Way.”  It is an honor to be able to teach his music and after 28 years of Plain and Fancy here at Amish Acres it would be a shame not to give the original composer the credit he is due.  So please enjoy the show and the music and thank you again for coming...and listening.   

Travis Smith

Plain and Fancy Cast


Dan King


Jeremy Littlejohn

Ruth Winters


Olivia Corbello

Katie Yoder


Nicole Tompkins

Papa Yoder


Travis Bird

Isaac Miller


Shelby Tyler Nichols

Emma Miller


Pam Gunterman

Hilda Miller


Sarah Philabaum

Ezra Reber


Ryan A. Schisler

Peter Reber


Justin Williams


Plain and Fancy Staff


Executive Producer


Richard Pletcher

Associate Producer


George Bush

Artistic Director


Jeremy Littlejohn

Music Director


Travis Smith

Production Stage Manager


Timothy James

Company Manager


Shelby Tyler Nichols

Technical Director


Tom Slavey



Erin Clossen

Set Designer


Richard Pletcher

Costume Designer


Amber Burgess

Lighting Designer


Jeremy Littlejohn

Properties Master


Timothy James

Box Office Manager


Jennifer Scheffer

Web Design


Brian Bell

Legal Representation


Dumler & Giroux, NYC

Archive Videographer


Steve Jones


Scenes and Musical Numbers

Act I


Scene 1 A Shell Station Outside of Lancaster


You Can't Miss It

Dan, Ruth, Company

Scene 2 The Road to Bird-in-Hand


It Wonders Me

Katie, Company

Scene 3 A Rest Stop Outside of Bird-in-Hand


Scene 4 The Yoder Yard


Plenty of Pennsylvania

Emma, Company

Young and Foolish  


Scene 5 The Yoder Parlor


Why Not Katie?

Ezra, Isaac

Scene 6 The Yoder Yard


Young and Foolish (Reprise)

Katie, Peter

Scene 7 The Little Room Under the Stairs


It's A Helluva Way to Run a Love Affair


This is All Very New to Me


Scene 8 The Yoder Yard


Plain We Live

Papa, Company

Scene 9 The Yoder Yard


The Shunning (Plain We Live: Reprise)

Papa, Katie, Company

Act II


Scene 1 The Yoder Yard


How Do You Raise a Barn?


Follow Your Heart

Peter, Katie, Hilda

Scene 2 The Yoder Kitchen


City Mouse, Country Mouse

Emma, Isaac

Scene 3 The Yoder Parlor


Scene 4 The Little Room Under the Stairs


I'll Show Him


Scene 5 The Reber Yard


Young and Foolish (Reprise)


Scene 6 The Yoder Yard


Finale (Plenty of Pennsylvania: Reprise)



Cast Biographies

Travis Bird (Papa Yoder) is blessed and excited to be joining the Round Barn Theatre’s 2014 season. Travis lives in Decatur, IN with his father and earned his Bachelor of Music in Voice performance at Ball Sate University. In college, he was a member of the BSU Chamber Choir and secretary of Down the Line Theater Company. He studied voice with Dr. Karri York and Dr. Kathleen Maurer. He was fortunate to be cast in Ball State Opera Theater’s Productions as Federico in L’amico Fritz and Bill in A Hand of Bridge under the direction of Mr. Joseph Levitt. One of his favorite roles was Don Octave in The Stoned Guest directed by the Round Barn Theater alum Julie Lyn Barber. His Wells Community Theater credits include Jesus in Godspell and the Artful Dodger in Oliver! directed by Kim Mann. He would like to take this opportunity to thank all of his family, friends and colleagues who have supported him throughout his journey!


Olivia CorbelloOlivia Corbello (Ruth) is a Texas State BFA grad from '12. She is so very pleased to be returning to Amish Acres where she played her favorite role to date, Patty Andrews in Sisters of Swing. She is currently living in NYC pursuing her love of the arts and song writing.
Love to Mom and Dad.






Pam GuntermanPam Gunterman (Emma) is excited to be a part of the 2014 season at The Round Barn Theatre. Pam lives just down the road in Bremen and has appeared in previous RBT productions including Camelot, Steel Magnolias, Seven Brides for Seven Brothers and Footloose earlier this summer.
I am thankful to my husband Tony for his continued love and support and to God for life and its endless opportunities.




Jeremy LittlejohnJeremy Littlejohn (Dan / Artistic Director) is so pleased to be returning to The Round Barn Theatre for his sixth season as Artistic Director. Jeremy grew up right down the road in Elkhart, Indiana and came to work at Amish Acres for the first time in 1997. He is probably remembered for his performance credits but is most proud of introducing plays to Round Barn Theatre patrons by way of the Second Stage. He has logged nearly 800 performances of Plain and Fancy playing all of the male roles; and directed the show six times, including the 20th Anniversary season. Onstage he has been seen as John Adams in 1776, Oscar in The Odd Couple, Archibald Craven in The Secret Garden, Sancho in Man of La Mancha, Tevye in Fiddler on the Roof, Yvan in Art, Bill Sykes in Oliver!, Froggy in The Foreigner, Caleb in The Spitfire Grill, and he can be seen this holiday season getting his “Ogre” on as the title role in Shrek.  Visit for more details.

Shelby Tyler Nichols (Isaac / Company Mgr.) is from Southeastern Georgia and a graduate of Valdosta State University. You may remember him as the Emerald City Guard in last year's The Wizard of Oz. He spends much of his time performing for children, whether it be all over the U.S. or overseas. Shelby is so very thankful to rejoin his family at The Round Barn and hopes you enjoy the season this year. He thanks everyone who has supported him along the way, especially his Mama, who is always there, no matter what.
Enjoy and God bless!


Sarah PhilabaumSarah Philabaum (Hilda) is thrilled to return for her fourth season at The Round Barn Theatre. You may remember her last season as Doralee in 9 to 5, Mavis in Church Basement Ladies 2: A Second Helping, Ruth in Plain and Fancy or Little Shop of Horrors this past spring. Sarah returns to Nappanee directly from Grand Lake, Colorado where she spent her summer with Rocky Mountain Repertory Theatre. During her time in Grand Lake, Sarah was fortunate to perform in Les Misérables, Shrek and the regional premiere of Hands on a Hardbody. Following Plain and Fancy, Sarah will once again be spending her holiday season touring the East Coast with Nebraska Theatre Caravan on her fifth tour of A Christmas Carol.
Special thanks to Jeremy Littlejohn for all that you do. You're wonderful and I wouldn't be here if it wasn't for you!

Ryan A. Schisler (Ezra) is a 2012 Murray State graduate from Owensboro, Kentucky. He was recently seen at Theatre West Virginia where he played the villainous Jim Vance in Hatfields and McCoys. Other favorite credits include Moonface Martin in Anything Goes and directing The Drowsy Chaperone.
I would like to thank my family for all their love and support.




Nicole Tompkins (Katie) is thrilled to be returning to The Round Barn Theatre stage where her most recent credit was State Fair. A graduate of Wright State University with a BFA in Acting, she has performed most recently in Dayton, OH and Clinton, IA.  Favorite credits include Maria in The Sound of Music, Illona in She Loves Me, and Portia in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice.
Much love and gratitude to my family and friends for their unwavering support while I pursue my dreams!



Justin Williams (Peter) is thrilled to be making his debut at The Round Barn Theatre! Justin is a Granger, IN native, but attended the American Musical and Dramatic Academy in NYC, NY. Some of his favorite roles include: Seymour in Little Shop of Horrors, Pippin in Pippin, Marius in Les Misérables and Bud Frump in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. Justin would like to thank Jeremy for this incredible opportunity!
Love and gratitude to Hannah and his family for their undying support and love!



Staff Biographies

Amber Burgess (Costume Designer) is pleased to be back at the Round Barn Theater for the incredible 2014 season.  She has been involved in theater (acting, costuming, and directing) since 1988.  Amber studied musical theater at Millikin University in Decatur, IL and also has a BA in Social Sciences (with an emphasis in theater) from Ashford University.  Amber has formerly worked as a costume designer with the Cincinnati Costume Company, Top Hat Productions (Marshall, MI), Cincinnati Landmark Productions, The Little Theater (Jamestown, ND), Millikin University (Decatur, IL), LaMoure County Theater (ND), and The Joseph Jefferson Playmakers (Jamestown, ND).  She was taught to sew as a child by her grandmother Jan Christopherson, and was taught dress making by her aunts Betsy Davis and Susan Ely.  When not at work she enjoys quilting, running, writing, and reading. She would like to thank her high school drama teacher, Karen H Crane for giving her first job as a costume designer 20 years ago. Karen, thank you for starting me on this path and inspiring me to become the person I am today. Amber is originally from Jamestown, ND and now lives in Chicago with her dog Oxford.  Visit

George Bush (Associate Producer) is a Nappanee native and proud graduate of Northwood High School! George began his work at Amish Acres as a trash collector at age 14 and spent much of his educational career (both high school and college) with Amish Acres as an intern, clerk in the hotel, Art Festival food runner and in retail.  George started a family in Muncie where he attended Ball State University and worked in the property development world for ten years. He returned to Nappanee in 2011, where he was named Chief Operating Officer for Amish Acres and Associate Producer for The Round Barn Theatre. He is extremely happy to have his family relocated back home and is looking forward to a wonderful 2014 season.

Erin Clossen (Sound) is a stage manager, director, and performer originally from Grand Rapids, Michigan. She has worked with many professional theatres including BoarsHead Theater, Williamston Theatre, Stormfield Theatre and White Heron Theatre Company as well as with Michigan State University’s Transforming Theatre Ensemble and MSU’s Institute for Arts & Creativity at Wharton Center. Favorite past projects include Spinning Into Butter (Sarah Daniels), How I Learned to Drive (Female Greek Chorus), The Most Massive Woman Wins (Director), For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls (Director), Among Friends (SM), Forbidden Broadway (ASM), All Childish Things (ASM)and The High Rise: A Comedy in Mask (Co-Writer, Featured Ensemble). Erin holds a BA in Theatre from Aquinas College.

Timothy James (Production Stage Manager) is from Anderson, SC and is pleased to be starting his career here at the Round Barn Theatre.  Timothy attended Anderson University where he received a B.A. in Theater with a Concentration in Theatrical Design. While at Anderson University, he learned that his passion for theater did not simply fall into one category. He have a love for all things in the theater whether it be acting or “behind- the- scenes”. Though his passion for theater is vast his focus still remains on Stage Management. Some of his favorite shows he has stage managed for would be The Misanthrope and A Raisin in the Sun, where he received nominations for the Kennedy Center American College Theater Festival,a local theater competition. He hopes to be just as successful while here at the Round Barn Theatre.  

Richard Pletcher (Executive Producer) founded Amish Acres with his father LaVern in 1968. The Amish farm was preserved and restored and is now listed in The National Register of Historic Places. Following a one year experiment in dinner-theatre with George Bledsoe in 1971, he added musical theatre to the interpretation of the historic farm by producing Plain and Fancy in the Locke Township Meeting House in 1986. It moved to The Round Barn Theatre in 1991. The play has been running for 26 consecutive years having surpassed 3,700 performances before audiences of over 355,000 people. Plain and Fancy’s Tony Award® winning author Joseph Stein and Tony Award® winning composer Albert Hague have attended Plain and Fancy at Amish Acres.

At Joseph Stein’s urging, Amish Acres became a regional musical repertory theatre in 1996 with the addition of five shows in rotation with Plain and Fancy each season. Amish Acres has now produced over one hundred Broadway musicals and The Round Barn Theatre stage is named for and dedicated to Joseph Stein. Seven of Mr. Stein’s musicals have been produced on his stage, including Plain and Fancy, Fiddler on the Roof, The Baker’s Wife, and Zorba, plus staged readings of Take Me Along, Rags and a second stage production of Enter Laughing.  

In October of 2006, Dick and his wife Susan were guests of Joseph and Elisa Stein in New York City for the York Theatre’s Mufti Series production of Plain and Fancy, the last in a month long, three show festival of Stein’s work that included Take Me Along and Carmelina. Artistic Director James Morgan recognized Amish Acres’ 20 year production of Plain and Fancy in the program and in his introductions from the stage. The Pletcher’s and Jeremy Littlejohn attended the York’s presentation of the Oscar Hammerstein Lifetime Achievement Award in Musical Theatre to Joseph Stein in November of 2007.  Stein was further inducted into the Theatre Hall of Fame in February of 2008. He passed away in 2010 and the Joseph Stein Memorial Fund was created to provide free season tickets for children.

Tom Slavey (Technical Director) was born and raised in Bremen, Indiana.  Upon graduation from Bremen High School, Tom moved to Los Angeles to pursue and enhance his love of music.  While in California, he learned carpentry, and started his own Construction business, while playing his music at night in the clubs of Hollywood and Orange County.  He moved back to Indiana to be of service to his immediate family, and to start his own.

Travis Smith (Music Director) is excited to be back at The Round Barn for another great season. Prior roles here include Abel Frake in State Fair, Amnesia in Nunsense A-Men, and the Tin Man in last season’s holiday production, The Wizard of Oz. He has also served as the resident Music Director for the past 4 seasons. In his free time, Travis is a freelance composer and arranger and is excited that one of his projects, Steeple People, will be presented here at Amish Acres in the Fall. Please check out for more information about Travis and Steeple People
Enjoy the show and thank you for supporting live theatre!


Plain and Fancy
Theme Dinner: May 30

Each Round Barn theatre Musical production calls for a Theme Dinner and Wine Bar, a joyous celebration with menus written with tongue-in-cheek show references and double entendres, often obscure and ridiculous. the responsibility for such frivolity rest solely with Richard Pletcher. The ensuing menus are lovingly prepared by chef Ruth Miller whose sense of humor make it into it kettle and skillet.

Theme Dinner reservations required. 
For reservations call (800) 800-4942.

Plenty of Pennsylvania

Broccoli and Cheese Soup

Tortilla Pinwheels
Fruit Kabob
Vegetables and Dip

Iceburg Lettuce Quarters with Tomatoes, Onions


Zucchini Bread
Pumpkin Bread

Swiss Steak with Mushrooms
Pan Fried Chicken

Boiled Red Potatoes, Baked in Olive Oil and Herbs

Asparagus Grilled
Candied Yams
Cooked Dried Corn

Old Fashioned Cream Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Shoofly Pie
Ruth's Famous Creme Brule

Iced Tea, Lemonade, Coffees
Beer and Wine available for purchase