Plain and Fancy Alumni
The Round Barn Theatre at Amish Acres is the National Home of Plain and Fancy, the 1955 Broadway musical about Amish life and love in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Since 1986, over 300,000 patrons have witnessed nearly 3,000 performances of the perennial show. This alumni roster is a tribute to the hundreds of actors who have kept the heartwarming story alive on the Joseph Stein Stage for nearly three decades.
1987 |
1988 |
1989 |
1990 |
Dennis Friesen-Carper |
Chevy Anz |
John DesLauriers |
Nick Anselmo |
Jessie Gray |
Sharon Camille |
Paul Friesen-Carper |
Rich Biever |
Cindy Horseman |
Beth Davis |
Sarah Friesen-Carper |
Heidi Dittmar |
Jeffrey Koep |
Laura Freeman |
Walter Marts |
Mark Gloor |
Jeffrey Little |
Randy Hock |
Josef D. McKesson |
Christopher Harrod |
Dennis McKeen |
Angie Linebeck |
Laura Oppelt |
Katie Hershberger |
|
Thomas Miller |
Paul Russell |
Bryan Johnson |
|
Alexander Oleksij |
Dianne Stone |
James Kidd |
|
Robert Penola |
Linda Van Polen |
Anthony Kienner |
|
Andrew Rhodes |
Glen Veteto |
Rebecca Noble |
|
Nancy Slusser |
Marie Vlasin |
Perry Ojeda |
|
Richard P. Snyder |
|
Robert Rais |
|
Margaret Wehrle |
|
Rockie Rodgers |
|
|
|
Dan Stetzel |
|
|
|
Colleen Tueth |
|
|
|
Ann Van Cleave |
|
|
|
Carroll Van Cleave |
|
|
|
|
1991 |
1992 |
1993 |
1994 |
John Abernathy |
Kathryn Ambler |
David Andrews |
Ken Bolander |
Lisa Barnett |
Stacy Baer |
Gary Cappelletti |
McKinley Carter |
Jon-Daniel Durbin |
Robert Clift |
Julie Crossen |
Erin Hall |
Carl Einbeck |
Darin Dahms |
Stephen Dunn |
Michael Klimzak |
Barry Gardner |
Amy Farrington |
Sarah Frascella |
Kent M. Lewis |
Tony Humrichouser |
Christopher Gurr |
Mitch Fuller |
Corey Moore |
Kelley Murphy |
Tanya Hardison |
David Gethmann |
Cathy Nichols |
Karen Smith |
Heather Morris |
Tim Jenson |
Jerry O'Boyle |
Juliet Steuer |
David Neuser |
Sherry Klinedinst |
Amy Penney |
|
|
Nancy Kolton |
Scott Saegesser |
|
|
Derek Krabill |
|
|
|
Anne Zawadzki |
|
1995 |
1996 |
1997 |
1998 |
Mary Beth Baugh |
Sara Heigaard |
Jerry O'Boyle |
Jerry O'Boyle |
Jim Beck |
Joe Lehman IV |
Linda Slein |
Sherry Klinedinst |
Bob Cline |
Cori Lynn Peterson |
Jose Simbulan |
Linda Slein |
Robert Geils |
Derek Phipps |
Eric Svejcar |
John Jay Espino |
Brian Herriott |
CeCe Pleasants |
Sari Ferraro |
Richard P. Snyder |
Val Landrum |
Richard Van Slyke |
Chris Barbee |
Colby Landers |
Cindy Lawrence |
Gene Westbrook |
Brian Engle |
David Esler |
Darrell Lormand |
A.J. Wester |
Jen Garde |
David Waterman |
Christine Manata |
Douglas Yockey |
Sara Heigaard |
Ryan Claus |
Benjamin Mannes |
|
Ken Baker |
Jessica Harrigan Texidor |
Lori L. Rhoda |
|
Christina Hobbs |
Peter Despotopolos |
Sheri Sanders |
|
Julie Barber |
Laura Freeman |
Jennie Sophia |
|
Matthew C. Scott |
Stanley Schorr |
|
|
Darrin Murrell |
Robert Geils |
|
|
Scott Saegesser |
Robin Aronson |
|
|
Leigh Conley |
Christine Asero |
|
|
Susan Beem |
Joby Raines |
|
|
Joby Raines |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
|
|
Fran Prisco |
James Ryan Caldwell |
|
|
Benjamin Green |
Scott Saegesser |
|
|
Jeffrey Sutton |
Val Landrum |
|
|
Robert Geils |
Aimee Miller |
|
|
Kacy Levy |
Sarajane Morse Mullins |
1999 |
2000 |
2001 |
2002 |
Jerry O'Boyle |
Jerry O'Boyle |
Scott Saegesser |
Scott Saegesser |
Jayson Elliott |
Al Fischer |
Becky Branch |
David Jenkins |
Lisa Hepler |
Laurie DeMunck |
Michelle Bouchard |
Heidi Ferris |
Andre Huff |
Ana Posey |
Natalie Ryder |
Michelle Bouchard |
Charles Rucker |
Becca McCoy |
Ben Hellman |
Lee Nollette III |
Scott Saegesser |
Susan South |
Brooke Geiger |
David Castaneda |
Dave Waterman |
Maura Pheney |
Jennie Sophia |
Paul Dodds |
Shana Leigh Herb |
Sam Brown |
Jessie Sullivan |
Patty Morgan |
Jessica Harrigan Texidor |
Jennifer Grace |
Keith Dykstra |
Scott Davis |
Robert Geils |
Jennie Sophia |
Ron O'Rourke |
Stacey Miehe |
Jennifer Cousin |
Pete Wehle |
Derek Martin |
Cheryl Szucsits |
Katherine Herron |
Scott Saegesser |
Cheryl Szucsits |
Joe Ford |
Erin Harding |
Heather Leichty |
Andrea DiGregorio |
Andrea DiGregorio |
Joe Clark |
Susan Yoder |
Rick Dakota Hart |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Jason Miller |
Stephanie Steidley |
Jacob Medich |
Sam Brown |
Lindsay Genshaft |
Andrea DiGregorio |
Casey Gensler |
J. Courtney Taylor |
Marcia Sofley |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Tim McCormick |
Emily Mackel |
Sam Brown |
Jacob Medich |
|
Stephanie Steidley |
Benjamin Green |
Aaron Fuksa |
|
Brooke Geiger |
Brian Madrigal |
Jason Lawergren |
|
Marcia Sofley |
Jacob Medich |
Rick Dakota Hart |
|
Derek Martin |
Rodd Bayston |
Jennifer Weaver |
|
Brent Hunsinger |
Tom Smith |
Greg Dvorak |
|
|
Margaret Eilertson |
Thad Engle |
|
|
|
Robert Geils |
|
|
|
Debbie Hetzel |
|
|
2003 |
2004 |
2005 |
2006 |
Scott Saegesser |
Scott Saegesser |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Heidi Ferris |
Heidi Ferris |
Heidi Ferris |
Brett Egan Schrier |
Michelle Bouchard |
Michelle Bouchard |
Michelle Bouchard |
Heidi Ferris |
Torger Baland |
Torger Baland |
Kristi Knobloch |
Phil Rittner |
David Castaneda |
David Castaneda |
Nathan Rux |
Nathan Rux |
Ben Szepesi |
Nathan Rux |
Jan Tobias |
David Castaneda |
Patty Morgan |
Kristi Knobloch |
Scott Saegesser |
Scott Saegesser |
Kristyn Yoder |
Jan Tobias |
Lisa Liaromatis |
Jan Tobias |
J. Courtney Taylor |
Jessica Costas |
Amber Burgess |
Sam Brown |
Derek Martin |
Derek Straat |
Kristyn Yoder |
Ariel Buck |
Jen Poiry |
Jeremy Jonet |
Sam Brown |
Shoshanna Richman |
Jessica Costa |
Jennifer Butler |
Claire Blakeley |
Killian Patton |
Chris Ference |
Jeff Salisbury |
Maggie Mountsier |
Daniel Steven Baker |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
David Friday |
Em Laudeman |
Em Laudeman |
Tracy Funke |
Cheryl Szucsits |
A. Michael Tilford |
Ashley Frost |
Jamie Lynn Sutton |
Erin Martin |
Jeff Salisbury |
Jennie Sophia |
Joe Ford |
Tracy Funke |
Melinda Parks |
Jason Sofge |
Doug Boes |
Michael Hartman |
Kristal Lockyer |
Joshua Rubin |
Martin Fox |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Justin Liebergen |
Matthew C. Scott |
|
Jared Lopatin |
Derek Martin |
Melinda Parks |
|
|
Jason Whicker |
Alison Rose Munn |
|
|
|
Paul Radford |
|
|
|
Jeff Salisbury |
|
|
|
Ian Strimple |
|
|
|
Daniel Gaouette |
|
|
|
Marcellus Waller |
2007 |
2008 |
2009 |
2010 |
Matthew C. Scott |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
David Craven |
Becky Wilson |
Phil Rittner |
Catherine Hammer |
Travis Smith |
Phil Rittner |
Denise Minter |
Travis Smith |
Phillip B. Richard III |
Brett Egan Schrier |
Katrina Stodd |
Amber Wines |
Emily Ledger |
Sam Brown |
Regina Warren |
Matt Green |
Corey McIntyre |
Paul Dodds |
Jayson Elliott |
Jackie Wolter |
Laurie Schotz |
David Castaneda |
Amber Burgess |
Jim DeSelm |
Jennifer Reber |
Scott Saegesser |
Emily Baer |
Olin Davidson |
Kirstin Flaglor |
Amber Burgess |
Jeffrey Funaro |
Matt Casey |
Luke Bridges |
Rachel Greene |
Sam Brown |
Crystal Davidson |
Alexa Jordan |
Heidi Ferris |
Matthew Callahan |
Cayla Solsburg |
David Jacobs |
Brian Kaisen |
Karen Courliss |
Erin Wolford |
Matt Casey |
Katie Fox-Kirsch |
Jeremy Hilgert |
Scott Alan Emerick |
Olin Davidson |
Richard Snyder |
Jason Sofge |
David Goins |
Jeremy Springer |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
Burke Fry |
Don Hart |
Blane Pressler |
Don Hart |
Joe Ford |
Crystal Day VanArtsdalen |
Cheyenne Nelson |
Jonathan Wilson |
David Smith |
Emily Baer |
Allison Jean Jones |
Tracy Funke |
Rachel Black |
Karen Courliss |
Sarah Koster |
Susan Yoder |
Trisha Hart Ditsworth |
Wesley Atkinson |
Kayla Bennett |
Jackie Wolter |
Jennifer Jackson |
Ryan Hazelbaker |
Emily Baer |
Stephanie Long |
Emily Thompson |
|
Nathan Mittleman |
Heather Bonahoom |
J.D. Simper |
|
Brian Duncan |
Ross Hannon |
Michael Wolter |
|
David Ryan |
Shaun McGuire |
Anthony Easterwood |
|
|
Martin Fox |
Ryan Yoder |
|
|
Daniel Steven Baker |
Lance Mullins |
|
|
2011 |
2012 |
2013 |
2014 |
David Craven |
David Craven |
|
|
Travis Smith |
Travis Smith |
|
|
Phillip B. Richard III |
Monica Gauer |
|
|
Mark Duggar |
Spencer Holdeman |
|
|
Katelyn Presnell |
Ted Lantz |
|
|
Spencer Holdeman |
Catherine Menkel-Lawrence |
|
|
Richard Vollmer |
Emily Baer |
|
|
Jeremy Springer |
Benjamin Lee Jackson |
|
|
Rachel Holland |
Evan Jackson |
|
|
Erin Whitcomb |
Katie Kuehner |
|
|
Daniel Stargel |
Caitlin Borek |
|
|
Rory Dunn |
Rory Dunn |
|
|
Megan Steigerwald |
Timothy Leonard |
|
|
Sarah Philabaum |
Sarah Philabaum |
|
|
Marilee Greene |
Vanessa Moyen |
|
|
Olin Davidson |
Olivia Corbello |
|
|
David Goins |
Matt Casey |
|
|
Michael Vaughn |
Dominic Go |
|
|
Paul Gregory Nelson |
James Bock |
|
|
Kate Salsbury |
Jeremy Littlejohn |
|
|
Emma Traubert |
J.D. Simper |
|
|
Rachel Stargel |
|
|
|
Emily Baer |
|
|
|
Diego Diaz |
|
|
|
David Coleman |
|
|
|
Samuel Ruhloff |
|
|
|
John Detty |
|
|
|
Allison Jean Jones |
|
|
|
