Theatre Reservations

    Package Reservations

Make Lodging Reservations


Plain & Fancy Catering by Amish Acres

Plain & Fancy Catering by Amish Acres

Plain & Fancy Catering

Download our Full Color Brochure!

After nearly 50 years of serving our award winning Threshers Dinner and a decade of fine dining in The Barn Loft Grill, we are now bringing the farm to you. Our offerings feature an endless option of culinary experiences for groups as small as 100 to as large as 2,000. From real butter & cream mashed potatoes to fresh baked pies from our own bakery, you will delight in the true country goodness we are known for. If the delicious flavor of outdoor cooking is what you're looking for, we also specialize in onsite grilled steak tips and mushrooms. Custom catering options are also available. Simply give us your ideas and budget and we'll develop a unique custom menu. Then relax...we'll do the rest!

Call to reserve your date today! 1-800-800-4942 •
1600 West Market St • Nappanee, Indiana


Plain & Fancy Catering

Great Beginnings

Plain and Fancy Catering


Garden Display
Fuit Kabobs
Antipasto Platter
Fresh Fruit Bowl
Sheese, Sausage and Cracker Tray
Ham & Turkey Deli Roll Ups
Jumbo Shrimp Tray


Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Maryland Crab Cakes

Our Famour Threshers Meal
An all time Favorite, Catered to your location

Choose Two Meat Entrees

Broasted Country Chicken
Cider-Bakers hickory smoked Ham
Tender Roast Beef

Dessert Placed on the Table

Shoo-fly Pie
Variety of fresh Fruit & Cream Pies
Vanilla Date Nut Pudding

Choose Two Beverages

Iced Tea

Plus, All of these Amish Acres Favorites

Basket of Amish Acres freshly baked Hearth Bread
Fresh Yellow Butter
Locally made Apple Butter
Last of the Garden Relish
Sweet & Sour Cabbage Salad
Green Beans with Smoked Side Meat
Mashed Potatoes
Sage Dressing & Giblet Gravy

Plain and Fancy Buffet
Choose from these freshly made entrees, salads vegetables, starches, breads and desserts!


Mixed Green Salad w/3 Dressings
Ruth's Classic Caesar
Spinach Salad
Sweet & Sour Cabbage Salad
Amish Potato Salad
Macaroni & Cheddar Salad
Colorful Bowtie Pasta Salad
Broccoli & Raisin Salad


Pulled Pork
Honey Baked and Hickory Smoked Ham
Slide Country Pork Loin
12 oz Bone in Pork Chop
Tender Beef Roast
Beef Brisket
Swiss Steak
Grilled Steak Tips & Mushrooms
Prime Rib
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Chicken Marsala
Roasted Turkey
Hearty Lasagna


Green Beans with smoked side meat
Cut Sweet Corn
Brown Sugar Glazed Baby Carrots
Green Bean Casserole with Fried Onions
Steamed Fresh Vegetable Blend


Whipped Real Mashed Potatoes
Garlic & Cheese Mashed Potatoes
Baked Three Cheese Macaroni & Cheese
Bake Potatoes Grade A Idaho
Twice Baked Potatoes with callions and bacon
Herb Roasted Baby Baked Potatoes
Fettuccine Alfredo


Wheat Dinner Rolls
Wheat Dinner Rolls


Freshly Baked Fruit Pies
Freshly Made Cream Pies
Shoo-Fly Pie
Assorted Cookes
Famous Cinnamon Torte
Chocolate Decadent Brownies

Rise & Shine
All breakfasts include coffee, juice, assorted sweet rolls, donuts, muffins, and sweet breads.

Ham & Cheese Egg Casserole
Scrambled Eggs, Pecan French Toast Bake, Sausage Links, Homestyle Country Fries

Lunch Options

Plain & Fancy Catering

Pulled Pork BBQ

Pulled Pork BBQ on Homemade Bread, Sweet & Sour Cabbage, Candied Sweet Pickle Mix, Potato Chips, Homemade Fudge, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Coffee

Chicken Salad Basket

Chicken Salad Sandwich, Sweet & Sour Cabbage, Candied Sweet Pickle Mix, Potato Chips, Homemade Fudge, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Coffee

Apple Butter BBQ Mini Meatloaf

Ruth's Homemade Meat Loaf, Mashed Potatoes and Green Beans, Cookie, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Coffee

Amish Haystack

Create your own Haystack by layering cracker crumbs, rice, seasoned ground beef, lettuce, celery, mild sauce, onions, tomatoes, lettuce, green peppers and cacho ships then top it all off with our delicious cheese sauce. Wash it all down with a refreshing beverage!

To complete your meal, add a slice of freshly baked hearth bread and spread on scrumptious Amish Church Peanut Butter. Enjoy Ruthie's delectable apple cake for dessert.

Deli Buffet
Plain & Fancy CateringRolled Turkey and Ham, Potato Salad, Pasta Salad, Fresh Fruit Salad, Vegetable Tray w/ dip, Cheese Tray & Crackers, Amish Acres Breads, Cookies, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Coffee

Box Lunches
Choice of Sandwich - Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef or Vegetarian on Homemad Bread of Wrap
Choice of Country Kettle Chips or Pretzels
Choice of Amish Potato Salad, Cole Slaw of Applesauce
Choice of Apple or Banana
Choice of Homemade Cookie or Brownie
Choice of Bottle of Soda or Water


Plain & Fancy Catering

  • All menus and pricing are subject to change
  • We can tailor any event to your individual needs
  • Please add 7% sales tax and 18% catering fee to all prices
  • All items can be picked up at Amish Acres and Service fee will be waived
  • Final count is due 10 days prior to event
  • All new guests are required to pay the day prior to the even
  • All returing guests are net 15
  • Prices quoted are for parties of 50 or more
  • There will be a 3% service fee attached to all invoices over $500 that are paid with credit cards
  • Our Formal Catering Package includes linen tablecloths for the buffet table and guest tables, skirting for the buffet tables. Linen napkins and an upgraded plate, glass and utensil package for $4.95 per person.